Drayton Harbor Projects
Monitoring:
Identifying Priority Areas and Measuring Success
What
is fecal coliform bacteria?
Fecal coliform
bacteria is found in human and animal feces. Although fecal
coliform may be harmless, when it's detected in a stream or the harbor,
it's a sign that human and/or animal wastes - and the harmful
micro-organisms that they may carry - are polluting the
water. Fecal coliform indicates that there is a public health
risk because of the potential of direct contact with sewage.
In addition, human and animal waste can contaminate shellfish and make
them unsafe to eat.
Where
does fecal coliform bacteria come from?
Possible sources
of of fecal coliform bacteria in the Drayton Harbor watershed are
failing septic systems, leaks in municipal sewer system, hobby or small
farms, large agricultural operations, pets, and wildlife.
How
much bacteria is in the harbor and neighborhood streams?
To guard against
public health risks, the state Department of Ecology has established
standards for bacteria in both fresh and marine waters. In
the harbor, there are two standards that must be met: water
samples must have less than an average of 14 fecal coliform colonies
per 100 milliliters of water (100 FC/100mL), and a 90th percentile of
less than 43 FC per 100mL. In neighborhood creeks, there are
also two standards that must be met: water samples must have
less than an average of 100 fecal coliform colonies per 100 milliliters
of water (100 FC/100mL), and less than 10% of the samples can have more
than 200 FC per 100mL.
Several agencies monitor water quality in Drayton
Harbor and the freshwater systems that drain into the harbor.
Maps and graphs have been developed to illustrate where samples are
being collected and the condition of water quality. Figure 1
delineates the boundaries of the Drayton Harbor Shellfish Protection
District. Figure
2 displays the various locations within marine waters where
samples are currently collected and Figure 3
shows what the water quality status is for each sample site.
The monitoring programs and water quality findings are described below.
How
is the water quality data used?
Water quality
monitoring plays a key role in both identifying priority areas for
water quality improvement and for measuring the success of programs in
these priority areas.
Water
Quality in Drayton Harbor
Marine
Water Standards for Fecal Coliform Bacteria
- Geometric mean less than 14 FC/100mL
- Estimated 90th percentile less than 43 FC/100mL
Shellfish
Growing Area
Eleven
monitoring sites have been established to classify
Drayton Harbor shellfish beds. The Washington State Department of Health (DOH) uses a minimum of the last
30 water samples to analyze water quality in comparison to the National
Shellfish Sanitation Standards. Samples are collected a minimum of six
times per year. Currently, samples are collected on a monthly
basis in Drayton Harbor. The Drayton
Harbor Annual Growing Area Review is prepared by DOH at the
end of each year.
Map
of DOH Drayton Harbor Sample Sites
Fecal coliform at each monitoring station is evaluated for both the geometric mean and the estimated 90th percentile. Currently, a portion of the harbor is classified as "Conditional Approval" with a six-day closure occurring after 3/4 inches of precipitation in 24 hours. DOH is considering a change to the "Conditional Approval" status that would result in a seasonal closure from November through February. The following table summarizes the geometric mean and estimated 90th percentile for each marine station under three conditions:
- All Ambient Data- All data that has been collected for Drayton Harbor during the last 30 sampling events has been analyzed.
- Rain Event Conditional Approval-All data, excluding periods with rain events greater than 3/4 inches in 24 hours, has been analyzed. A minimum of 30 samples are analyzed for each station.
- Seasonal Conditional Approval- All data excluding sampling events in November, December, January, and February each year has been analyzed. A minimum of 30 samples are analyzed for each stations.
**Values in this table are approximations for illustration of water quality status at each sampling station. DOH calculations provide the official values that are used for shellfish growing area classifications.
Summary Table
Port
of Bellingham
The Port samples
the waters of the Blaine Marina as well as sites in the harbor, outside
of the harbor and in the Semiahmoo Marina. The fecal coliform levels
within the Blaine Marina have been consistently high. This closed
system makes it hard to flush out contaminants that enter the harbor at
this point.
Map of Port of Bellingham
Drayton Harbor Sample Sites
Water
Quality in Neighborhood Creeks
Fecal Coliform Bacteria Freshwater
Standards for Drayton Harbor
- Geometric mean less than 100 FC/100 mL
- Not more than 10% of samples exceed 200FC/100mL
Fecal Coliform Bacteria Freshwater Standards for Boundary Bay
- Geometric mean less than 50 FC/100 mL
- Not more than 10% of samples exceed 100FC/100mL
Long-Term
Monitoring Program
The Northwest
Indian College (NWIC) has been sampling several sites in the Drayton Harbor watershed for fecal coliform bacteria since 1998. Samples have typically been collected on a monthly basis. Some stations have been sampled less frequently due to dry conditions or, in previous years, due to limited funding.
The NWIC currently samples eight sites on Dakota and California Creeks. Based upon the past
30 samples, only two of these eight sites are meeting both thresholds of
the water quality standard. Six of the eight sites have more
than 10% of the samples exceeding 200 FC/100mL.
Additionally, the NWIC currently samples two sites at Cain Creek. These sites discharge into Boundary Bay and have higher standards of water quality that must be met. Freshwater discharging to Boundary Bay must have a geometric mean less than 50 FC/100mL and less than 10% of the samples exceeding 100 FC/100 mL. Based upon the last 30 samples, both of these sites exceed both thresholds of the fecal coliform water quality standard.
Map of Northwest Indian College
Drayton Harbor Watershed Sample Sites
Status
of Long-Term Monitoring Sites through May 2010
Site
|
Geometric
Mean
(FC/100mL)
|
%
Exceeding 200
(FC/100mL)
|
Status*
|
C1
|
50.6
|
3.3%
|
|
C2
|
78.9
|
23.3%
|
|
C3
|
74.3
|
26.7%
|
|
D1
|
59.4
|
20.0%
|
|
DG
|
53.2
|
16.7%
|
|
D2
|
45.0
|
13.3%
|
|
D3
|
57.6
|
16.7%
|
|
D4
|
54.4
|
10.0%
|
|
CC*
|
57.5
|
36.7%
|
|
CCO*
|
217.4
|
76.7%
|
|
Calculations
based upon last 30 samples.
*Green indicates meeting both water quality standard thresholds, orange indicates exceeding one threshold, red indicates exceeding both thresholds.
**See water quality standards for Boundary Bay above.
Annual Geometric Means for California, Dakota, and Cain Creeks
California Creek Data Table 2007-2010
California Creek Data Chart 2007-2010
Short-Term
Monitoring Projects
The
Washington State Department of Ecology (DOE) conducted a Total Maximum
Daily Load (TMDL) study in the Drayton Harbor watershed from December
2007 through December 2008.
TMDL Monitoring Plan
1st Quarter
Progress Report
2nd Quarter
Progress Report
3rd Quarter
Progress Report
4th Quarter
Progress Report
Hirsch
Consulting Services conducted a year-long monitoring project on
California Creek tributaries from April 2006 through May 2007.
Final Report
Other
Drayton Harbor Projects
On-site Septic Systems
Municipal Sewer Systems
Agricultural
Practices
Boats/Marinas
Stormwater Runoff
Wildlife/Non-human
Contributions
Other Sources
Education and
Community Involvement
Data Management/Water
Quality Monitoring
Reports
Whatcom County Public Works- Natural Resources
322 N. Commercial, Suite 110, Bellingham, WA 98225 USA
Contact Us: • (360) 676-6876 • Office Hours M-F 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Last
updated 06/02/10
|